Collaborative novels like The Castle Keepers are on trend for good reason—they bring fresh perspectives and layered storytelling. Written by Aimie K. Runyan, J’nell Ciesielski, and Rachel McMillan, this book weaves three tales of love, war, and resilience. While the concept is solid, it didn’t wow me.
Set during the Gilded Age, the Great War, and post-WWII, the stories follow three women navigating societal constraints and class divisions. The setting—a castle overshadowed by a family curse—adds an air of mystery that unites the narratives.
The novel shines with its strong female characters, rich historical detail, and intriguing themes. The first two novellas stood out: Beatrice’s rise from scandal in “The Truth Keepers” and Elena’s tender bond with a disfigured soldier in “The Memory Keepers” were packed with emotion and depth. However, the final novella, “The Dream Keepers,” shifted focus to Alec’s postwar struggles, leaving Brigitta’s perspective underdeveloped and breaking the female-driven pattern.
The romances, while heartfelt, felt predictable, and the varied writing styles didn’t always flow seamlessly. Still, the historical snapshots and the Alnwick family drama added complexity. The book effectively explores how love and war shape both people and places, even if it stumbles in consistency.
The Castle Keepers is a solid choice for historical fiction fans, offering characters to root for—and to loathe. 
3.5 rounded up to 4 stars
** Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review.