All We Were Promised transports readers to 1837 Philadelphia, where three young Black women—Charlotte, Nell, and Evie—struggle against societal constraints and personal secrets. Charlotte, who recently escaped slavery, lives as a servant to her white-passing father in a city she thought would guarantee her freedom. Nell, from a wealthy, freeborn Black family, is passionate about the abolitionist cause and introduces Charlotte to the movement. Their paths intersect with Evie, Charlotte’s old friend, who remains enslaved and longs for escape.
The story delves into the meaning of freedom, both physical and emotional, as each woman seeks a better future in a city simmering with racial unrest and anti-abolitionist sentiment. Lattimore enriches the narrative with historical details, particularly around the building of Pennsylvania Hall, a symbol of antislavery activism later destroyed by pro-slavery forces.
Though the pacing lags in the first half, the stakes intensify as Nell and Charlotte’s plan to help Evie escape unfolds, revealing the risks each character must take for their ideals. The novel’s strength lies in its well-developed characters and their complex emotions, as well as the stark contrasts it draws between safety and true freedom.
All We Were Promised is an insightful exploration of Black resilience and the bonds of friendship in a time of turbulence. Lattimore’s research shines through, offering a fascinating look at 1830s Philadelphia and widening perspectives on Black American experiences. A compelling debut deserving of 4 stars.
** Thanks to the publisher for a comp of this book in exchange for a fair review. The opinions are my own.